Hello friends!
Today we’re heading to the United States, specifically New York, to make a recipe that I love. I’ve been wanting to make these for ages but never took the time. Today, that changes with authentic American bagels!
An iconic specialty of New York
When we think of New York, we often envision the towering skyscrapers, yellow taxis, Central Park, and Times Square. However, there’s another essential institution: the bagel.
It’s nearly impossible to spend a few days in the city without encountering a specialty shop. New Yorkers are crazy about bagels and enjoy them at all times of the day: be it for breakfast, lunch, or on the go between appointments.

I admit that every time I see those magnificent sandwiches filled with cream cheese, smoked salmon, or crisp vegetables, I’m instantly tempted to prepare some at home.
And honestly, there’s something very satisfying about making your own authentic American bagels. Their signature shape, slightly firm texture on the outside, and soft interior. All of this adds to the pleasure.

A very special ingredient
There’s one ingredient that I found consistent across all the recipes I studied: “barley malt syrup,” which is exactly what it sounds like. I didn’t have this ingredient, so I looked for alternatives: honey or molasses.
I opted for pomegranate molasses, and the result was fantastic. So, I encourage you to choose what suits you best or what you can find most easily.

A story that travels through the centuries
Although bagels are now closely associated with New York, their history begins far from the United States.
Their origins trace back to Central Europe, particularly within Jewish communities in Poland. Immigrants brought their recipes with them when they settled in North America at the end of the 19th century.
In New York, bagels quickly became a staple of street food. Specialized bakeries multiplied, and the recipe became ingrained in the daily lives of the residents.
What I love about this specialty is precisely its ability to traverse cultures. A recipe born thousands of miles away that ultimately becomes one of the culinary symbols of an iconic city like New York.

What makes the bagel unique
The hallmark of the bagel lies in its preparation method.
Unlike traditional bread, bagels undergo a poaching stage in water before baking. This step is precisely what gives it its unique texture and color. It’s akin to the process for pretzels.
The first time I discovered this technique, I found it quite surprising. Ultimately, it’s this step that makes all the difference.
Poaching results in a slightly shiny crust and a denser crumb compared to traditional bread. This is precisely what we are after in an authentic American bagel.

A thousand ways to fill them
Once your bagels have cooled, the hardest part finally begins: choosing the toppings.
The most famous version is probably the one with cream cheese and smoked salmon: a great classic that never fails.
But the possibilities are nearly endless. Ham, cheese, avocado, scrambled eggs, grilled vegetables, or even a sweet version with butter and jam.
At my place, everyone customizes their bagel according to their preferences. This makes the recipe especially friendly for hosting friends or family.
Simply place a variety of toppings in the center of the table, and everyone can create their ideal bagel. It’s perfect for a delightful brunch.

I tell you everything
As often in baking, patience is your best ally.
Respect the rising times to achieve a soft and airy dough. A dough that hasn’t risen sufficiently will produce much denser bagels. Don’t overlook the kneading time either, as it contributes significantly to the authentic texture of American bagels.
I also recommend preparing all your ingredients in advance before poaching. This step goes by quickly, and it’s more convenient to have everything at hand. You’ll be surprised by the color of the poaching water if you use molasses like I did. Don’t worry, that’s normal!
Finally, feel free to customize your bagels with sesame seeds, poppy seeds, or even a mix of both. It’s simple but adds a lot of flavor.

A gourmet journey without leaving your kitchen
This is exactly the kind of recipe I love to make on weekends.
One takes their time, discovers a different know-how, and a few hours later, it feels as if you’ve traveled without ever leaving your kitchen.
And what a joy it is to take those beautiful golden bagels out of the oven! I assure you, the aroma alone will entice you to sit down at the table.
If you’ve never made them at home, I believe you’ll be pleasantly surprised. Once you’ve tasted them, it becomes difficult to go back to store-bought versions.

The necessary utensils
A stand mixer with a dough hook,
One electronic scale (to ensure uniform dough pieces),
A large saucepan,
And one baking mat.
There you go, you know everything!
The recipe, Chef!
Authentic American Bagels
Homemade American bagels, with malt syrup or molasses raised dough, dipped in a salted water bath then sprinkled with sesame seeds.
Ingredients
- Dough
- 260 g of warm water
- 5 g of dried baker's yeast
- 10 g of malt syrup (or molasses)
- 10 g of brown sugar
- 500 g of T55 flour
- 10 g of salt
- Bath
- 2 liters of water
- 1 teaspoon of salt
- 1 tablespoon of malt syrup (or molasses)
- Finishing
- Sesame seeds
Instructions
Dough
Dissolve the yeast in warm water.
Pour the rest of the dough ingredients into your mixer bowl.
Start kneading on low speed while pouring the water with the yeast in a thin stream.
Knead until the dough comes away from the sides of the bowl.
Cover with a clean cloth and let it rise for at least 1 hour and 30 minutes until it doubles in volume.
After that time, take the dough, divide it into 10 pieces.
Shape each piece into a ball, then insert your thumb into the center of the ball and gently stretch to form a circle of dough.
Place on a baking tray and let it rest for 30 minutes.
Bath
Pour the ingredients into a large pot. Bring to a boil, then reduce to a gentle simmer.
Drop your bagels into the water, one by one or two at a time depending on the size of the pot.
Let them cook for 30 seconds on each side, then place them on two baking sheets lined with parchment paper.
Finishing
Preheat your oven to 210 degrees.
Sprinkle the bagels with sesame seeds.
Bake for 20 to 22 minutes.
Let cool on a rack before tasting.
FAQ
Why boil bagels before baking them?
Poaching is the essential step for achieving an authentic bagel. It gives the bagel its fine, slightly shiny crust while retaining a dense, fluffy crumb.
What is the difference between a bagel and a classic bread?
Unlike traditional bread, a bagel is first poached in water before baking. This double cooking gives it its distinctive texture.
Can you freeze homemade bagels?
Yes, bagels freeze very well. Cut them in half before freezing so that they can be heated directly in the toaster.
Which flour should be used for making bagels?
All-purpose flour is ideal. A flour with a higher protein content will achieve a texture even closer to authentic New York bagels.
Why are my bagels too hard?
Overcooking, excessive poaching, or insufficiently hydrated dough are the most common causes.
How can you garnish a bagel?
The most popular toppings include smoked salmon and cream cheese, chicken avocado, ham and cheese, or even a sweet version with spread or jam.





No Comments